When it comes to choosing a mattress, it’s essential to consider your specific needs, preferences, and budget. Two reputable brands offering high-quality mattresses are Stearns and Foster vs Saatva.
In this detailed comparison, we’ll delve into the critical aspects of each brand’s mattresses to help you decide which one is the best fit for you.
Saatva Mattress
Saatva is a popular online mattress brand known for its eco-friendly and luxurious innerspring mattresses. They offer multiple firmness options to cater to a wide range of sleepers. The Saatva Classic mattress, the brand’s flagship model, is designed to provide excellent back support, making it suitable for hot sleepers, people with back pain, back sleepers, and stomach sleepers.
The Saatva Classic mattress features a unique coil-on-coil design that provides robust support, durability, and a bouncy feel. The mattress’s top layer is covered with a plush Euro pillow top that adds extra cushioning and pressure relief. Saatva offers a 365-night trial period and a lifetime warranty, which speaks to the confidence they have in their products.
CHECK LOWEST PRICE
Stearns and Foster Mattress
Stearns and Foster is a renowned luxury mattress brand with a long-standing reputation for producing premium, handcrafted mattresses. The brand’s most popular model, the Stearns and Foster Estate, is a memory foam mattress designed to provide excellent pressure relief and support.
The Estate mattress features a Tencel cover that is soft, breathable, and eco-friendly. The comfort layers consist of memory foam and a unique Intellicoil system that adapts to your body’s contours and provides targeted support. This mattress is suitable for those suffering from joint or hip pain, as well as back and side sleepers.
Stearns and Foster offer a 365-night trial period and a lifetime warranty, which is a testament to their commitment to quality and customer satisfaction.
Key Differences
The most significant differences between Saatva and Stearns and Foster mattresses lie in their construction, materials, and overall feel. Saatva offers innerspring mattresses with a more traditional and bouncy feel, while Stearns and Foster’s memory foam mattresses provide a more conforming and pressure-relieving experience.
In terms of firmness, Saatva offers multiple options, making it suitable for a wider range of sleepers. Stearns and Foster’s Estate mattress is medium-firm, which might be more limiting in terms of individual preferences.
Stearns and Foster vs Saatva Mattress Overview
In this section, we’ll discuss the types of sleepers who might prefer each mattress, taking into account factors such as sleeping position, pain relief, and temperature preferences.
Who Should Get the Saatva Mattress?
The Saatva mattress is an excellent option for:
- Hot sleepers: The innerspring construction and breathable materials help regulate temperature, ensuring a cool and comfortable night’s sleep.
- Back pain sufferers: The Saatva mattress offers robust lumbar support, which can help alleviate discomfort and promote proper spinal alignment.
- Back and stomach sleepers: The multiple firmness options available cater to the unique support needs of back and stomach sleepers.
Who Should Get the Stearns and Foster Mattress?
The Stearns and Foster mattress is ideal for:
- Joint and hip pain sufferers: The memory foam and innerspring hybrid design provide targeted pressure relief to alleviate discomfort.
- Back and side sleepers: The medium-firm feel of the Stearns and Foster mattress offers a balance of support and cushioning, accommodating both back and side sleepers.
- Those who value luxurious materials: The Stearns and Foster mattress features high-quality materials and craftsmanship, making it an excellent choice for those seeking a luxury sleeping experience.
What Do the Saatva and Stearns and Foster Mattresses Feel Like?
The Saatva mattress offers three firmness levels, providing options for various preferences. Its innerspring construction delivers a responsive and bouncy feel, ideal for combination sleepers, while also ensuring excellent edge support.
On the other hand, Stearns and Foster mattresses are known for their luxurious comfort and a range of firmness options. The hybrid design combines innerspring support with memory foam contouring, resulting in a balanced sleep surface suitable for most sleeping positions. The mattress also features a solid edge support system and a premium, luxurious feel attributed to its high-quality materials.
Firmness and Feel Differences
In this section, we’ll explore the firmness levels and unique feels of the Saatva and Stearns and Foster mattresses, as well as how they cater to different body types and sleeping positions.
How Firm Are the Saatva and Stearns and Foster Mattresses?
The Saatva Classic mattress comes in three firmness levels: Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm. This variety allows sleepers to choose a mattress that best suits their needs and preferences. In contrast, the Stearns and Foster Estate mattress has a medium-firm feel, rated at 6.5 out of 10 on the firmness scale.
Sleeping on the Saatva and Stearns and Foster Mattresses
The Saatva mattress offers excellent support and pressure relief for back and stomach sleepers due to its coil-on-coil design. The various firmness options allow sleepers to find the perfect balance between support and comfort.
The Stearns and Foster mattress, on the other hand, is better suited for side sleepers and those with joint or hip pain. The memory foam layers conform to the body’s contours, providing targeted pressure relief and support.
Related: Saatva vs Heavenly Bed
Mattress Construction Differences
In this section, we’ll take a closer look at the construction of the Saatva and Stearns and Foster mattresses, examining the components that contribute to their unique characteristics and performance.
Cover
The Saatva Classic mattress features an organic cotton cover that is soft, breathable, and hypoallergenic. This eco-friendly cover adds a luxurious touch to the mattress while ensuring a comfortable sleeping surface.
The Stearns and Foster Estate mattress has a Tencel cover, which is made from sustainable wood pulp fibers. This cover is known for its breathability, moisture-wicking properties, and silky-soft feel, contributing to a cooler and more comfortable night’s sleep.
Comfort Layers
The comfort layers of the Saatva Classic mattress consist of a plush Euro pillow top, followed by a layer of memory foam for added pressure relief. These layers provide a cushioning effect, while the coil-on-coil construction ensures adequate support.
In the Stearns and Foster Estate mattress, the comfort layers include memory foam and a layer of their patented Intellicoil system. This combination offers excellent contouring and pressure relief, adapting to the sleeper’s body shape for a more personalized sleep experience.
Support Layers
The support layer of the Saatva Classic mattress features a dual coil system, with a layer of individually wrapped pocketed coils on top of a layer of steel innerspring coils. This design ensures proper spinal alignment, reduces motion transfer, and provides long-lasting support.
The Stearns and Foster Estate mattress incorporates the Intellicoil support system, consisting of individually wrapped coils that provide targeted support and minimize motion transfer. The combination of memory foam and coils ensures proper spinal alignment and pressure relief for a more comfortable sleep experience.
Mattress Height
The Saatva Classic mattress is available in two heights: 11.5 inches and 14.5 inches. The choice of thickness allows for customization based on personal preferences and the desired aesthetic.
The Stearns and Foster Estate mattress has a height of 14.5 inches, which gives it a luxurious and plush appearance.
Saatva vs Stearns & Foster Performance Differences
In this section, we’ll compare the performance of the Saatva and Stearns and Foster mattresses in various categories, such as temperature regulation, motion isolation, and durability.
Sleeping Hot or Cold
The Saatva Classic mattress sleeps relatively cool, thanks to its breathable organic cotton cover and innerspring construction that promotes airflow. This mattress is an excellent choice for hot sleepers or those living in warmer climates.
The Stearns and Foster Estate mattress also sleeps cool, primarily due to its Tencel cover and the gel-infused memory foam layer that helps dissipate heat. However, some sleepers may still experience heat retention due to the mattress’s overall memory foam construction.
Motion Transfer
The Saatva Classic mattress has minimal motion transfer due to its individually wrapped pocketed coils, making it a suitable choice for couples or light sleepers who are easily disturbed by their partner’s movements.
The Stearns and Foster Estate mattress performs well in terms of motion isolation, as the memory foam layers and individually wrapped coils work together to minimize movement transfer across the mattress.
Edge Support
Both the Saatva Classic and Stearns and Foster Estate mattresses offer excellent edge support, thanks to their respective coil systems. This feature is essential for those who like to sleep or sit near the edge of the mattress, as it prevents sagging and provides a consistent sleeping surface.
Durability
Saatva and Stearns and Foster are both known for their high-quality, durable mattresses. The Saatva Classic’s dual coil system and the Stearns and Foster Estate’s Intellicoil system contribute to the long-lasting support and comfort that these mattresses offer. With proper care, both mattresses should last at least 7-10 years.
Off-Gassing
The Saatva Classic mattress, with its innerspring construction, has minimal off-gassing, as it contains fewer foam layers compared to a memory foam mattress. Any initial odor should dissipate quickly.
The Stearns and Foster Estate mattress may have some off-gassing due to its memory foam layers. However, the odor is generally mild and should dissipate within a few days. To speed up the process, it’s recommended to air out the mattress in a well-ventilated room before using it.
Noise
The Saatva Classic mattress, with its innerspring construction, might produce some noise over time, particularly as the coils begin to wear. However, the individually wrapped pocketed coils help reduce noise levels compared to a traditional innerspring mattress.
The Stearns and Foster Estate mattress is relatively quiet due to its memory foam layers and individually wrapped coils. This mattress is an excellent option for those sensitive to noise during sleep.
Sex
The Saatva Classic mattress, with its bouncy and responsive coil-on-coil design, is more suitable for sex compared to a memory foam mattress. The mattress offers better motion and ease of movement, which is an essential consideration for some couples.
The Stearns and Foster Estate mattress, though not as responsive as an innerspring mattress, still provides adequate support and comfort during sex. The memory foam layers and the Intellicoil system work together to offer a balanced feel that accommodates various activities in bed.
Saatva vs Stearns and Foster Pricing
Saatva
| Size | Dimensions | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Twin | 38″ x 75″ | $887 |
| Twin XL | 38″ x 80″ | $1,148 |
| Full | 54″ x 75″ | $1,595 |
| Queen | 60″ x 80″ | $1,695 |
| King | 76″ x 80″ | $2,095 |
| Cal King | 72″ x 84″ | $2,095 |
Stearns & Foster
Pricing based on current Estate model
| Size | Dimensions | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Twin Long | 38″ x 80″ | $2,299 |
| Full | 54″ x 75″ | $2,349 |
| Queen | 60″ x 80″ | $2,399 |
| King | 76″ x 80″ | $2,999 |
| Cal King | 72″ x 84″ | $2,999 |
Company Policies
Understanding the company policies for both the Saatva and Stearns and Foster mattresses is essential when making your purchase decision. In this section, we’ll compare their warranty, sleep trial, and return policies.
Warranty Info
Both Saatva and Stearns and Foster offer lifetime warranties for their mattresses, which cover defects in materials and workmanship. This warranty indicates the brands’ commitment to quality and customer satisfaction.
Sleep Trial
Saatva and Stearns and Foster both provide 365-night sleep trials, allowing customers to test their mattresses for a full year before deciding whether to keep or return them. This generous trial period ensures that customers can make an informed decision about their purchase.
Return Policy
If, during the sleep trial, you decide that the Saatva or Stearns and Foster mattress isn’t the right fit for you, both companies offer hassle-free returns. They will arrange for the mattress to be picked up and donated or recycled, and you’ll receive a full refund.
Saatva Mattress vs Stearns and Foster Mattress FAQs
Which mattress is better, Saatva or Stearns and Foster?
There is no definitive answer, as the best mattress depends on individual preferences, needs, and budget. The Saatva Classic mattress offers a more traditional innerspring feel, while the Stearns and Foster Estate mattress provides a memory foam experience.
Evaluate your sleeping position, comfort preferences, and specific requirements (e.g., pressure relief, temperature regulation (1), and motion isolation) to determine which mattress is the better choice for you.
Are Saatva and Stearns and Foster mattresses good for back pain?
Both Saatva and Stearns and Foster mattresses offer excellent support and pressure relief, which can help alleviate back pain. The Saatva Classic mattress, with its coil-on-coil construction and various firmness options, is particularly well-suited for back and stomach sleepers.
The Stearns and Foster Estate mattress, with its memory foam layers and Intellicoil system, conforms to the body’s contours and provides targeted support, making it an excellent choice for side sleepers and those with joint or hip pain.
How long do Saatva and Stearns and Foster mattresses last?
Saatva and Stearns and Foster mattresses are known for their durability and high-quality construction. With proper care and maintenance, both mattresses should last at least 7-10 years.
The lifetime warranties offered by both companies demonstrate their confidence in the longevity of their products.
Can I try Saatva and Stearns and Foster mattresses in-store?
Saatva is primarily an online mattress brand, but they do have a few showrooms in the United States where you can try their mattresses. Check the Saatva website to find a showroom near you.
Stearns and Foster mattresses are available in various brick-and-mortar stores across the country. Visit the Stearns and Foster website to find a retailer near you where you can test their mattresses in person.
How do Saatva and Stearns and Foster mattresses arrive?
Saatva offers free white glove delivery, which includes in-home setup and old mattress removal. The mattress is not compressed or rolled, arriving fully expanded and ready for use.
Stearns and Foster mattresses are also delivered using a white glove service, with in-home setup included. They typically arrive uncompressed and ready to use, depending on the retailer’s delivery service.