Embarking on the quest to find the perfect mattress can be daunting, especially when faced with top contenders like the Plank and Saatva mattresses. In this “Plank mattress vs Saatva” comparison, we’ll help you navigate the intricate world of these two exceptional options, each offering its own unique set of features.
With Saatva’s luxurious innerspring construction and Plank’s innovative foam design, the choice between these mattresses might leave you feeling uncertain.
Fear not, as we’ll provide an in-depth analysis of their advantages, disadvantages, and distinctive characteristics to help you determine the ideal option for your sleep preferences.
Let’s dive into the Plank and Saatva mattress showdown and guide you towards a restful night’s sleep.
Plank Mattress vs Saatva Overview
Who Should Get the Saatva Mattress?
- Sleepers who prefer a luxury innerspring feel
- People who sleep hot and need a mattress with good airflow
- Couples who need good motion isolation and edge support
- Those who want multiple firmness options
Who Should Get the Plank Mattress?
- Sleepers who want a firm, supportive sleeping surface
- Back and stomach sleepers looking for proper spinal alignment
- Those who prefer a foam mattress without the sinking feeling
- Sleepers who want a flippable mattress with two firmness options
- Both mattresses cater to a wide range of sleepers by offering multiple firmness options.
- They provide excellent support for back and stomach sleepers.
- Both mattresses have impressive edge support, making them suitable for couples who share a bed.
- They both utilize high-quality materials designed for durability and long-lasting comfort.
- Saatva and Plank have exceptional customer service, sleep trials, and warranties.
- The Saatva mattress is a hybrid innerspring model, while the Plank mattress is an all-foam model.
- The Saatva offers better temperature regulation and breathability due to its coil system, whereas the Plank mattress may sleep warmer.
- The Saatva mattress is available in two height options (11.5″ and 14.5″), while the Plank is available in one height (11.75″).
- The Plank mattress has a flippable design with two firmness options in one mattress, whereas the Saatva offers separate firmness choices.
Firmness and Feel Differences
How Firm Are the Saatva and Plank Mattresses?
The Saatva mattress is available in three firmness options: Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm. The Plush Soft is rated as a 3 out of 10 on the firmness scale, the Luxury Firm as a 6, and the Firm as an 8.
The Plank mattress is a flippable design, featuring a firm side and an extra-firm side. The firm side is rated as a 7 out of 10 on the firmness scale, while the extra-firm side is rated as a 9.
Sleeping on the Saatva and Plank Mattresses
Sleeping on the Saatva mattress provides a luxurious feel, with a plush pillow-top surface that contours to your body, while the innerspring support system offers excellent spinal alignment. Side sleepers will find the Plush Soft option more comfortable, while back and stomach sleepers will prefer the Luxury Firm or Firm options.
The Plank mattress offers a firmer sleeping experience. The firm side provides a balanced mix of comfort and support, while the extra-firm side is ideal for those who need maximum support.
Back and stomach sleepers will appreciate the firm support and proper spinal alignment provided by both sides of the Plank mattress.
Side sleepers who prefer a firmer surface may also find the firm side comfortable, but those who need more pressure relief may not find the Plank mattress suitable.
What Do the Saatva and Plank Mattresses Feel Like?
The Saatva mattress has a luxurious, traditional innerspring feel with a plush pillow-top surface that offers a good amount of contouring. The coil system provides excellent support and responsiveness, making it easy to move around on the mattress.
The Plank mattress has a firmer, denser feel, thanks to its all-foam construction. It does not have the same level of contouring as the Saatva, but it still provides adequate pressure relief for most sleepers. Its flippable design allows sleepers to choose between a firm and an extra-firm surface.
Average Weight Sleepers – 130 lbs – 230 lbs
For average weight sleepers, the Saatva mattress provides a good balance of comfort and support in all three firmness options. Side sleepers will likely prefer the Plush Soft or Luxury Firm options, while back and stomach sleepers will find the Luxury Firm and Firm options most suitable.
Average weight sleepers will likely prefer the firm side of the Plank mattress, as it provides a supportive and comfortable surface for back and stomach sleepers. Side sleepers may find the firm side comfortable if they prefer a firmer surface, but those who need more pressure relief might not find it ideal.
Heavyweight Sleepers – Over 230 lbs
Heavyweight sleepers will appreciate the support provided by the Saatva mattress, particularly in the Luxury Firm and Firm options. The innerspring system ensures proper spinal alignment and prevents excessive sinking.
The Plank mattress is also a good option for heavyweight sleepers, as its firm and extra-firm sides provide ample support and prevent sagging. The all-foam construction may not offer the same level of responsiveness as the Saatva, but it still performs well for this weight category.
Lightweight Sleepers – Under 130 lbs
Lightweight sleepers will find the Plush Soft option of the Saatva mattress most comfortable, as it provides adequate pressure relief and contouring. The Luxury Firm option may also be suitable, but the Firm option might feel too hard for this weight category.
On the Plank mattress, lightweight sleepers may find the firm side comfortable, particularly back and stomach sleepers who prefer a firmer surface. Side sleepers who need more pressure relief might not find the Plank mattress suitable, as both sides are quite firm.
Mattress Construction Differences
The Saatva mattress features an organic cotton cover with a Euro-style pillow top, providing a soft and breathable surface. The Plank mattress has a quilted polyester cover that is removable and washable, offering a smooth and durable surface.
The Saatva mattress has a comfort layer consisting of polyfoam and memory foam, providing pressure relief and contouring. The Plank mattress has two comfort layers, one on each side. The firm side features a layer of high-density polyfoam, while the extra-firm side has a layer of even denser polyfoam.
The support system in the Saatva mattress consists of a layer of individually wrapped coils and a layer of steel support coils. This system provides excellent support, responsiveness, and durability. The Plank mattress has a high-density foam support core, which offers a firm and supportive base for both sides of the mattress.
The Saatva mattress is available in two height options: 11.5″ and 14.5″. The Plank mattress has a single height option of 11.75″.
You May Also Like: Lull vs Saatva
Saatva vs Plank Performance Differences
Sleeping Hot or Cold
The Saatva mattress performs well in temperature regulation due to its coil system, which allows for better airflow and breathability. The organic cotton cover also adds to its cooling capabilities.
The Plank mattress, being an all-foam model, may sleep warmer for some individuals. However, its firm surfaces help prevent excessive sinking, which can reduce heat retention.
Both the Saatva and Plank mattresses perform well in motion isolation. The Saatva’s individually wrapped coils help minimize motion transfer, while its foam layers absorb movement. The Plank’s all-foam construction also isolates motion effectively, making both mattresses suitable for couples who share a bed.
The Saatva mattress has reinforced edges, providing excellent edge support and preventing sagging. The Plank mattress also has strong edge support due to its firm and supportive foam layers. Both mattresses are suitable for couples who need more sleeping space or for those who tend to sleep near the edge of the bed.
Both the Saatva and Plank mattresses are made with high-quality materials designed to last. The Saatva’s coil system and premium foam layers provide long-lasting support and comfort. The Plank’s high-density foam layers also contribute to its durability. With proper care, both mattresses should have a lifespan of around 7-10 years.
As with most foam mattresses, the Plank mattress may emit a slight off-gassing odor when first unpacked. However, this should dissipate within a few days in a well-ventilated room. The Saatva mattress has minimal off-gassing due to its coil system and organic cotton cover.
The Saatva mattress may produce some noise due to its innerspring system, but this is generally minimal and should not be a significant concern for most sleepers. The Plank mattress, being an all-foam model, is virtually silent when bearing weight.
The Saatva mattress provides a more responsive surface for sex, thanks to its innerspring system. The Plank mattress, while firmer and less bouncy, still offers a supportive surface that should be suitable for most couples.
Saatva vs Plank Mattress Pricing
|Twin||38″ x 75″||$887|
|Twin XL||38″ x 80″||$1,148|
|Full||54″ x 75″||$1,595|
|Queen||60″ x 80″||$1,695|
|King||76″ x 80″||$2,095|
|Cal King||72″ x 84″||$2,095|
|Twin||38″ x 75″||$799|
|Twin XL||38″ x 80″||$849|
|Full||54″ x 75″||$999|
|Queen||60″ x 80″||$1,149|
|King||76″ x 80″||$1,349|
|Cal King||72″ x 84″||$1,349|
- Saatva: Lifetime warranty
- Plank: 10-year limited warranty
- Saatva: 365-night sleep trial
- Plank: 120-night sleep trial
- Saatva: Full refund minus a $99 transportation fee if returned within the sleep trial period
- Plank: Full refund with free returns if returned within the sleep trial period
Saatva Mattress vs Plank Mattress FAQs
Which mattress is better, Saatva or Plank?
The Plank is better suited for those who prefer a firmer, more supportive surface. If you are a back or stomach sleeper who needs extra support to keep your spine aligned, the Plank’s firm feel may be the better choice.
On the other hand, if you are a side sleeper or prefer a more plush feel, the Saatva’s pillow-top and coil-on-coil construction may provide the necessary cushioning and pressure relief. Ultimately, the decision between the two mattresses will depend on your individual preferences and needs.
How long will the Saatva and Plank mattresses last?
Both the Saatva and Plank mattresses are designed with high-quality materials to ensure durability and longevity.
The Saatva has a lifetime warranty, while the Plank has a 10-year limited warranty. However, the lifespan of any mattress depends on various factors, such as usage, maintenance, and the sleeper’s body weight.
With proper care and maintenance, the Saatva and Plank mattresses can last for many years and provide excellent value for their respective price points.
Can you flip the Saatva or Lull mattress?
Neither the Saatva nor Lull mattresses are designed to be flipped. However, they can be rotated every 3-6 months (1) to promote even wear and prolong their lifespan.